Hi Aiko, thank you so much for your honest feedback! It sounds like the length is just right, but the snugness around the toes might be due to the square toe shape as it can sometimes feel a bit more fitted, especially at first. The leather we use for this pair is designed to soften and mold to your feet with wear, so we recommend giving it a few more tries to break in. Most of our customers find that it becomes much more comfortable after a short adjustment period. That said, if it still feels too tight after breaking in, feel free to reach out and we’ll be happy to help in any way we can. We hope you get to enjoy these shoes soon!