Hi Grace, thanks for writing us a review. We're sorry to hear your feedback with regards to the craftsmanship of your pair. We will extend your feedback to our shoemakers. As for the leather, please note that it has a semi-matte finish because the leather is waterproof. Lastly, the lightness of the shoe is a feature that we are proud of too. The soles we use for these shoes are purposely lightweight to provide ease of wear and all-day comfort for the everyday user. Thanks again for your feedback ♥️